Magento to Shopify Migration: Is It the Right Move for Your Business?

If you’ve ever had an idea of migrating away from Magento to another CMS then this post is for you. At the moment of publishing(early 2025) some stats give the first place to Shopify and others to Woocommerce in global ecommerce market share. Let’s briefly discuss Magento to Shopify migration

In this article, we’ll explore:

• The key differences between Magento and Shopify

• The benefits of migrating from Magento to Shopify

• Real-world feedback from merchants who made the switch

• Who should consider migrating—and who should stick with Magento

Magento vs Shopify: A Quick Overview

Magento, now Adobe Commerce, is a highly customizable, open-source platform popular among large-scale retailers with complex needs. It’s powerful but requires significant technical resources and development expertise.

Shopify, on the other hand, is a fully hosted, user-friendly SaaS platform ideal for small to medium-sized businesses. It offers faster setup, lower maintenance, and extensive app integrations.

Why Businesses Migrate from Magento to Shopify

Here are the top reasons businesses are making the move:

1. Lower Development & Maintenance Costs

Magento requires a dedicated development team or agency to handle updates, security patches, and custom features.  Shopify offers a plug-and-play model that significantly reduces ongoing costs.

2. Faster Time to Market

Shopify stores can go live in days or weeks, while Magento projects can take months to build and optimize.

3. Better User Experience

Shopify’s streamlined backend makes it easier for non-technical teams to manage products, orders, and content.

4. App Ecosystem & Integrations

Shopify’s App Store offers thousands of extensions that can be installed without custom development.

5. Scalability Without Complexity

With Shopify Plus, even enterprise-level businesses can scale operations without worrying about hosting or performance issues.

Real-World Feedback from Merchants Who Succesfully Migrated from Magento to Shopify

1. Techwear Retailer in Germany (B2C, Mid-size)
“We spent over €20,000 a year just maintaining our Magento store. With Shopify, we’ve cut that by 60% and improved our conversion rate by 18%. I just wish we’d moved sooner.”
— Markus L., E-commerce Manager

2. Organic Cosmetics Brand in the UK
“Magento gave us flexibility, but we constantly needed developers. Shopify made it easy for our marketing team to launch campaigns and edit pages. The built-in SEO tools are also a huge plus.”
— Anita R., Brand Founder

3. Specialty Food Company (USA)
“We had recurring issues with Magento updates breaking things. Shopify offered a stable, predictable environment. Our customer support team also found it easier to handle orders and refunds post-migration.”
— Michelle F., COO

4. Ethical Fashion Brand (Germany)
“Our small team was overwhelmed managing Magento. With Shopify, we regained control. It’s easier to run promotions, manage inventory, and connect with influencers thanks to native integrations.”
— Frederike P., Founder

Real-World Feedback from Merchants Who Stayed with Magento

1. Industrial Equipment Supplier (Germany, B2B):
“We considered moving to Shopify, but our site handles over 40,000 SKUs with tiered pricing, customer-specific discounts, and complex ERP integration. Magento gives us the backend flexibility that Shopify simply can’t match.”
— Stefan R., Head of Digital Commerce

2. Fashion Marketplace with Multi-Vendor Setup (Italy):
“Magento allows us to manage hundreds of vendors, regional storefronts, and custom product types. It’s not cheap to maintain, but it’s irreplaceable for our model.”
— Elena C., CTO

3. Automotive B2C+B2B Hybrid Store (USA):
“We needed a platform that could support custom-fit parts filters, VIN lookup, and B2B logins with special pricing. Shopify Plus couldn’t handle our business logic without extensive workarounds. Magento was already built to do it.”
— Josh M., Operations Lead

4. Automotive Parts Distributor in the US (B2B)
“We tried moving to Shopify, but we hit a wall with our complex catalog and pricing rules. In the end, we returned to Magento with custom solutions.”
— Jason T., CTO

Who Should Migrate from Magento to Shopify?

✅ Shopify is a Great Fit If:

• You want to reduce development costs

• Your team lacks in-house technical resources

• You’re looking for faster speed to market

• Your store doesn’t require complex custom workflows

• You value ease of use and built-in SEO features

❌ You May Want to Stay on Magento If:

• Your store has highly complex, custom features

• Advanced B2B functionalities needed (custom pricing, tiered accounts)

• You have a dedicated development team and can manage ongoing maintenance

• The store rely on third-party systems that are tightly integrated with Magento

Final Thoughts

Magento to Shopify migration can unlock agility, reduce costs, and empower marketing and operations teams with a more intuitive platform. However, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Complex B2B operations or stores heavily dependent on customization may still find Magento a better long-term fit.

Whether you’re considering the switch or already planning your move, carefully weigh your needs, resources, and goals. A thoughtful migration strategy can set your business up for long-term growth and scalability.